About the Foreigner series: Spoiler alerts

There is the general spoiler page for general questions.

I’m making this set of pages for more specific questions.

The rule is: do not ask or comment about a book until it has been at least a month in issue. I think that will make everybody happy re spoilers.

363 Comments

  1. stellarwin

    I wonder, if Nand Geigi and Nand Cajeiri both see a future table without strife and mortal competition and recognize a value in such arrangement, than more is changing than the average Ateva would imagine? Hmm, with respect to children, I have recently thought that Bren should be surprised with a child from his not to remote past. A lover prior to Barb, who produces a daughter and doesn’t inform Bren. Maybe a love from his college days? A young lady of Cajeiri’s age group? On a roll, I wondered what would happen if Bren were suddenly provided an heir, and she came to live with him on the mainland. My imagination does wander a bit.

    • chakaal

      Except Cajeiri was born significantly after Bren hits the mainland so his postulated daughter would likely be more like a teen-ager than nearly 9. Assuming Bren would have neglected to take precautions to that extent which I’d have a hard time believing of him…

    • Silverglass

      Well, his old girlfriend/casual date Sandra Johnson (remember her, from early in the series?) DID have a son named Brent….awfully similar name, to my mind…Obviously not a match for Cajeri, but Damiri is pregnant again…Probably too many years between her next child and any hitherto-unknown child of Bren’s, though.

      All this speculation. I’m very deep into the series again. Found myself thinking today, “what does one have to do next weekend?” This can only get more pronounced as I go on.:)

  2. tulrose

    And then we would see Bren develop an ulcer …

    • brensgirlfriday

      Oh yeah… his ulcers would have ulcers.

  3. IsleAnsuz

    Thankfully he’s got over that sort of namby pamby self doubty stuff.
    Then again, having a kid might be considered a “Quiet” episode for him… lol

    So, to keep it sorta on topic:
    CJ, whilst the science from Uptop could enable this sort of thing, what’s your personal opinion on Interspecies cross breeding happening within the Foreigner-verse?

  4. forceten

    CJ,

    Some stupid questions.

    (1) Are the Edi and the Gan different races of atevi (like Caucloids and Mongloids are different races of humans)? Or are they simply different clans?

    Since the Edi, especially, are the aboriginal people of an archipelago that contained Mospheira it would suggest that at the very least they had very distinct culture and language due to that isolation, right?

    Finally on this topic who populates the rest of the archipelago other than Mospheira? If you had to compare Mospheira to an island on Earth how large is it? Greenland? New Guinea? Or smaller like Ireland or Britain?

    (2) Are there any maps of the world of the atevi?

    Thank you!

  5. CJ

    They have a racial difference, subtle to human eyes; and their culture and political system is different, hence the difficulty assimilating them into the aishidi’tat. Mospheira is about the size of Britain without Scotland, a little smaller, and without the number of isles—there are some, but none of great size in the north. Crescent Island to the south is about like Corsica.

    • Busifer

      Hmn, having visited Corsica a number of times I have full respect for how large a “small” island can seem… (it’s very mountainous, with small roads)… so why aren’t there any townships? Or are there, only we have’t heard of them (except the failed development)? Was it too evacuated? I think I remember some reference saying Mospheiran expansion plans had been approved by Tabini (or some committee, lol?) – was it evacuated and then forbidden for humans to use, to create some buffer zone?

      • Busifer

        (OK, so this should teach me to read further down the thread before asking questions 😉 – the answers are all there, already!)

  6. forceten

    Wow so Mospheira is the size of England, Wales, and Cornwall combined? Not big. Poor humans!

    Are the Edi and Gan the same race, or are they two different races from each other as well as Ragi?
    Are all the rest of the aishidi’tat (e.g., Eastern associations) also Ragi in race?

    Who lives on Crescent Island? Humans or Atevi?

    Thank you so much. I kept putting Deceiver down to sort it out. It appears that the Edi are a nationless enclave within the aishidi’tat – sort of like how many Cornish feel! I haven’t gotten to the end yet so I don’t know if the Dowager’s succeeded in giving them a lordship (the Cornish haven’t gotten their own parliament or recognition as a constituent country either!)

  7. CJ

    The Edi and Gan look a little different, but do not distinguish themselves as two races, more like two tribes or cultural groups. Crescent Island is arid and not so nice in the main, and it is ceded to humans. And the Ragi as a specific clan are closely culturally connected (to the point of identity) with the Atageini and Kadagidi and Taibeni, but most of all Tabini, head of the Ragi clan, maintains strong ties to the Taibeni, which is a situation the Atageini and Kadagidi detest: the Taibeni they view as rural and rough, sort of country cousins, and Tabini’s adhering most to the Taibeni makes a lot of central Ragi-related clans upset to the point of craziness.

    Wasn’t it in the 1800’s that the world lost the last native Cornish speaker?

  8. forceten

    Interesting. So the Edi and Gan are one race with different cultures. The mainland atevi are another race. So there are two distinct races of Atevi. Humans only really have three so that makes sense.

    With respect to the Cornish I’m not sure it ever went fully extinct but it is certainly endangered. There’s been a revival of sorts – there are about 2,000 fully fluent speakers in Cornwall; a good number of them are under 30 raised bilingual so that’s a good thing. With it now being listed as a minority language, used on signs, and I believe taught in schools it’s likely to survive and grow like Irish has and to a lesser extent Welsh and Manx, and to a much, much lesser extent Scots Gaelic and Scots. At least it won’t be like the British language which is completely extinct. Breton survives in Brittany but they were not the same. Neat stuff though.

    Are there different local/regional languages in the aishidi’tat? You’d think with the years of isolation before they found each other there’d have been separate languages. And even within the larger regions there probably would have been different languages due to the isolation from each other and difficulty of travel. Surely the Edi and Gan speak a different primary language than the Western Association.

    We need a companion book about the Atevi’s world; sort of a Rivan Codex-like thing! 🙂

    • brensgirlfriday

      Oh, you mean Cornish is still kicking? Oh good. You hate to see a language die… I know a tad -nay, a pittance!- about a great many languages, nothing to write home about, but still… one of my previous acquaintances was a linguist, or claimed to be. It was nice to learn about things. It’s nice to learn a dead language isn’t, in any case. That companion book would be quite welcome.

  9. Silverglass

    I believe the current population of London itself is in the millions; that’s not even counting the rest of England, nor the rest of the UK. In Foreigner, didn’t Bren tell Cenedi that the population of Mospheira was somewhere in the 400,000 range? So I don’t suppose they’re very crowded; there must be a good bit of wild country on the Island. I’d love to see a map of just Mospheira, but also one of the mainland; I’m not really clear on how big it is.

    One of the things I love best about the series is the importance the atevi put on wild places, on the conservation of natural resources, and their insistence on only hunting each creature within a specific season. The idea of appreciating the fact (when eating meat) that you have taken a life, of being cognizant of this during the meal, is very appealing to me.

    And this leads me to a question I have been meaning to ask: CJ, what is the state of religion in general among humans on the atevi world? Bren makes reference to God, but organized religion doesn’t seem to play any part in his life (not that he has a lot of time for it!) Just wondering…religion in SF and fantasy is a particular interest of mine.

    • CJ

      Some are religious: Bren didn’t have that in his upbringing.

  10. iminnocent

    Silverglass,

    in Foreigner Bren told Cenedi that the population on Mospheira was just over 4 million.

    • Silverglass

      Ooops, I was undercounting by a factor of ten! Thanks, iminnocent! I didn’t have the book handy to check.

  11. William

    i remember Jase to Bren 6 million humans and the remaning crew was 1200 or so

  12. sleo

    I just found these books a few months ago and have gobbled them up ASAP. Just ordered the last two in hard cover. Was delighted to find the third trilogy at B&N in eformat as I have a Nook! Where are these maps you speak of?

    I cracked up reading comments from April/May about Bren and Jago having a daughter — I remember grinning in Destroyer when Bren made a comment about how lethal Jago is in relation to Barb and her presence on the boat when Toby takes them all to the mainland after their return to earth. What a hoot.

    Anyway, I just love the stories and the world and the atevi. Thanks, CJ.

  13. sleo

    CJ, are there any plans to publish the newest trilogy in eformat? I do like to read things on my Nook, although the hard covers are lovely. I just got them today.

  14. CJ

    So far it’s up to Penguin and Amazon, and some are, some aren’t.

  15. brensgirlfriday

    I really liked the Foreigner cover art of Bren… And then the last one we read… the one with the ah, -fete- at the Southern? Lord’s holding where Bren had to go and reason with the man. He looked a very veritable unhappy camper on that cover. CJ, Mom and I cannot wait for more. Your work is excellent intellectual food. It’s like blocks of nutrition for the brain! And guys, what’s Nook? All I ever hear about is Kindle… I know there are other E-Readers, but…

  16. sleo

    Nook is the ereader sold by Barnes & Noble. I got it instead of Kindle because it’s more versatile. I can get books from other sources besides B&N and also rent library books. There are several out there. Google ereaders.

    • brensgirlfriday

      Oh! Okay! Thank you very much!

    • sweetbo

      I have a Kindle and I buy books besides those on Amazon. Not sure why people think Kindles can only work Amazon books. Just isn’t true. B&N sales people must have flexible ethics if they are saying otherwise.

  17. William

    Note to kindle and other book readers remember the betamax vcrs

    • sleo

      William – Do you think something better is coming out?

      • Shadow007

        My own take on that is to “strip” the DRM out of any DRMized book I buy and save it on my netbook.

        But SURE I’ll have to make sure that any content I buy/get I transfer along when Technology moves along…

        • tulrose

          I’m with Sweetbo. There’s lots of other places to buy books that work on a kindle. You can’t borrow library books (yet). I just find that Amazon has more ebooks than B&N.

        • sweetbo

          I’m not worried about “losing” any Amazon book because of that reason. There will always be a nerd out there able to free my books for me should Kindle go under. I’m sure the technology will morph, but so will the safety nets. Unlike the physical transition between VHS and DVD, digital stuff can be converted in most cases. These books are mostly just XML anyhow. Where there is a nerd there is a way.

  18. sleo

    I looked at charts comparing features when I bought my Nook. Perhaps Amazon has added features since then. Also I do remember seeing instructions for Kindle downloads on other sites so my apologies. Library books are a boon though.

Submit a Comment